The annual Autocar road testers’ Christmas lunch isn’t just a festive meal; it’s a tradition where the team champions their favorite car from the past year. This year’s event saw a diverse lineup, from eco-conscious hybrids to roaring V8 muscle cars, each vying for the title of standout vehicle.
The Contenders
The selection process is simple: each tester brings a car they genuinely believe deserves recognition, either for its personal appeal or overall excellence. The judge, staff writer Sam Phillips, has the final say. This year’s contenders included:
- Toyota Prius Plug-In Hybrid: Championed for its efficiency, reliability, and continued relevance in a shifting automotive landscape.
- Ford Mustang Dark Horse: A raw, unapologetically fun muscle car with a manual gearbox, representing a defiant spirit in an era of electrification.
- Porsche Panamera Turbo S: A luxurious PHEV blending performance with practicality, offering both electric range and a thrilling V8 experience.
- Morgan Supersport: A quirky, lightweight rear-wheel-drive sports car evoking a unique, almost steampunk aesthetic.
- Renault 5: A modern electric revival capturing the spirit of affordable, fun small cars of the past.
The Arguments
Each tester presented their case. James Disdale defended the Prius, arguing its enduring practicality and efficiency make it a standout in uncertain times. Illya Verpraet championed the Mustang Dark Horse, celebrating its visceral driving experience. Steve Cropley highlighted the Panamera’s versatility, blending luxury, performance, and reasonable efficiency. Matt Prior’s pick, the Morgan Supersport, was praised for its unique character and pure driving pleasure.
Vicky Parrott’s selection, the Renault 5, stirred debate. She argued it recaptured the magic of classic small cars, offering affordability and fun without compromise. The Renault 5 stood out, not just for its electric powertrain but for its ability to reignite the joy of accessible motoring.
The Verdict
After deliberation, Sam Phillips declared the Renault 5 the winner. Phillips noted the car’s blend of retro charm, decent range, and affordability makes it a standout in a market increasingly focused on practicality and sustainability. The Renault 5 isn’t just a good EV; it’s a revival of the fun, accessible small car that once defined a generation.
“The 5 has brought a whole new narrative to the electric car debate, proving that EVs can be fun and good to drive but also inexpensive without feeling cheap.” – Sam Phillips
The Road Ahead
The Christmas lunch underscored a key trend: the automotive landscape is diversifying. From efficient hybrids to high-performance EVs, the industry is offering a wider range of choices than ever before. Whether it’s the practicality of the Prius, the thrill of the Mustang, or the charm of the Renault 5, there’s a car for every driver.
The event also highlighted the enduring appeal of classic motoring experiences. The Morgan Supersport reminded everyone that pure driving pleasure still has a place in a modern world. Ultimately, the Autocar Christmas showdown wasn’t just about cars; it was about celebrating the joy of driving and the spirit of automotive passion.
