The small car market is heating up, with Toyota and Citroen both vying for dominance in the budget hybrid segment. The Toyota Aygo X, once a bare-bones city car, has evolved into a premium-feeling urban crossover with a hybrid powertrain. Meanwhile, Citroen’s C3 offers a compelling alternative, boasting more space and a lower price point. This comparison breaks down which model offers the best value and driving experience.
The Toyota Aygo X: Style and Efficiency
Toyota has significantly revamped the Aygo X, moving away from its shared origins with Citroen and Peugeot. The latest model now features a hybrid engine borrowed from the larger Yaris, alongside a refreshed exterior. While the update brings performance improvements, it also comes with a price increase; the current Aygo X starts at £21,595, making it pricier than many rivals.
Key Specs:
- Price: £21,595
- Powertrain: 1.5-litre 3-cylinder hybrid, 114bhp
- 0-62mph: 9.2 seconds
- Fuel Efficiency: 55.3mpg
The Aygo X’s hybrid system delivers a punchy driving experience, especially in urban environments. Its nimble chassis makes it fun to drive, though the narrow tires (175-section) limit grip in wet conditions. Higher trim levels, like the Excel, offer a well-equipped package, and the optional Premium Pack adds a JBL sound system and a canvas sunroof for £1,350.
The Citroen C3: Comfort and Value
Citroen’s C3 takes a different approach, prioritizing comfort and affordability. It undercuts the Aygo X by a considerable margin, starting at £19,035 for the hybrid variant. The C3 also offers more interior space and a larger boot, making it more practical for families or those who frequently carry cargo.
Key Specs:
- Price: £19,035
- Powertrain: 1.2-litre 3-cylinder hybrid, 108bhp
- 0-62mph: 9.8 seconds
- Fuel Efficiency: 42.8mpg
Citroen’s Advanced Comfort suspension provides a smoother ride than many competitors, though it comes at the expense of sharper handling. The infotainment system is user-friendly, and the driver display is integrated into the top of the dashboard. However, locating the trip computer requires some digging through the controls.
Head-to-Head: On the Road
The Aygo X excels in urban agility, while the C3 prioritizes ride comfort. The Toyota’s hybrid powertrain is responsive, making it ideal for city driving, whereas the Citroen’s softer suspension encourages a more relaxed pace. The automatic gearbox in the C3 can feel hesitant at times.
Fuel Economy: The Aygo X delivers better real-world fuel efficiency (55.3mpg vs. 42.8mpg), but the C3’s larger fuel tank (44 liters vs. 30 liters) allows for longer stretches between fill-ups.
Practicality: The C3 offers more rear passenger space and a larger boot, making it the more sensible choice for those who need room for passengers or luggage.
Ownership and Verdict
Toyota offers an impressive 10-year warranty with franchise servicing, but service plans are expensive. Citroen’s extended warranty is slightly shorter at eight years but more affordable.
Winner: Citroen C3
The Citroen C3 emerges as the winner due to its superior value, spacious interior, and comfortable ride. While it lacks the Aygo X’s sporty handling, it excels in practicality and affordability.
Runner-up: Toyota Aygo X
The Aygo X is a solid choice for those prioritizing style and efficiency. Its hybrid powertrain delivers good performance, but its cramped interior and higher price point hold it back.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual needs. If space and value are paramount, the Citroen C3 is the clear winner. If you prioritize style and a more engaging driving experience, the Toyota Aygo X remains a competitive option.
